MUMBAI: The Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) has published
information on biosafety studies of Bt brinjal, developed by MAHYCO, on
its official website. The data in eight volumes, runs into more than
1,100 pages.
Sources in the Department of Biotechnology (DBT) confirmed that it was
the complete data sent by the company which was analysed by the
department and forwarded to the GEAC. Greenpeace, which has been
demanding that the data be made public and is involved in a long Right
to Information (RTI) battle, says the data looks comprehensive, but
there is neither an official notification nor an assurance of its
completeness from the authorities.
However, MAHYCO had sought a stay on the data being made public after an
order of the Central Information Commissioner (CIC) last November. The
Delhi High Court did grant the stay in December 2007 after MAHYCO, the
Indian partner of the multinational agri biotech giant Monsanto, said
the company could suffer commercial losses if the confidential data was
disclosed to the public.
In the last hearing of the case in Delhi on August 20 there was no
mention of the data being available on the website. Since the issue was
sub judice and the DBT was one of the respondents it could not make the
data public. DBT sources said there was nothing secret about the data
and the only reason it did not share it with Greenpeace was because of
the company's objections as a third party that their business interests
would be affected. Now GEAC in its own wisdom has decided to post the
data on the Internet.
Greenpeace said it has been close to 30 months since the first
application for the biosafety data and minutes of the Department of
Biotechnology (DBT) committee meetings were submitted under the RTI Act
2005 by Divya Raghunandan. Since then the data was consistently denied
by the DBT till the CIC directed the department to disclose the data to
the appellant finally in November 2007.
Though it had come very late, this was a welcome step by GEAC, said
Divya Raghunandan of Greenpeace who had filed the RTI way back in
February 2006. Recently, Dr. P.M. Bhargava, special invitee of the
Supreme Court in the GEAC, raised concerns on the veracity of the Bt
cotton as well as the Bt brinjal data as the procedures followed were
flawed.
|